Network Working Group R. Watson
Request for Comments: 115 J. North
NIC 5822 Stanford Research Institute (ARC)
16 April 1971
SOME NETWORK INFORMATION CENTER POLICIES ON HANDLING DOCUMENTS
INTRODUCTION
The Network Information Center (NIC) seeks to facilitate the flow of
information between sites on the Network and to and from other
stations whose work makes them valuable as participants in the
Network dialog. The NIC is concerned both with the techniques for
the flow and with optimizing the content of the information itself.
Some aspects of the work of the NIC in support of information flow
are described here, and some suggestions made to Network participants
of ways they can help this work.
All information handled by the NIC is available to any Network
participant. All information generated by the NIC is unclassified
and is without distribution limitation except as dictated by staff
and budget size. Any information sent by an originating party to the
NIC for recording or distribution is presumed to be unclassified and
without distribution limitations as well. Any statement carried by a
document thus submitted which seems to imply a limitation on
distribution, quotation, or citation is presumed not to apply to its
handling by the Network Information Center.
NIC NUMBER
One important function of the Network Information Center is to make
records of the existence of RFC's, formal NIC-related manuals and
reports, Network memos, other Network informational items, and other
informational items of interest to Network participants, and to index
these records so that such items can be recalled when needed.
To tag the informational items a serial number is assigned by NIC.
The serial number has no intrinsic meaning, not even necessarily an
indication of sequence of issue. It is a unique identifier and can
be used to refer to the item in further communications, to facilitate
indexing, and to allow numeric filing of documents.
Watson & North [Page 1]
RFC 115 Policies on Handling Documents 16 April 1971
Use of the NIC number has advantages in online dialog which are not
yet demonstrable around the Network, but the cooperation of Network
participants in applying one when a document is originated is
important.
THE NIC CATALOG
Items of information relevant to the Network appear in many forms,
including technical reports, RFC's, brief network memos, journal
articles, and letters. Reference to these is simplified by
assignment of a NIC number to each. To record the item to which the
NIC number refers, a description of each item, using a set of
standard data elements, i.e, author, title, etc., is coded and
entered as an online system (NLS) statement into a machine file.
An example of a statement with typical coded data elements:
(A5480) *a1 James E. White #2 org *b2 University of California
at Santa Barbara #3 Computer Research Laboratory #5 Santa
Barbara, California *c1 An NCP for the ARPA Network #6 142p.
*d1 21 December 1970 *f1 r *f2 o *rl UCSB CRL 12 *31 ARPA #6 AF
19628-70-0-0314 *w2 3-11-71 *y1 Describes program designed and
implemented at Santa Barbara node of ARPA Network, written in
assembly language and implemented on 360/75. Discusses
interface with hardware, software, and operator. *y3 Host-
Interface protocol; Host-IMP protocol; User-NCP protocol;
Host-Host protocol; Host-IMP messages, IMP-Host messages *z1
all *z2 NIC *z3 new *
The group of files at ARC containing these statements of data about
NIC items and other informational items is the Master Catalog. The
term NIC Catalog refers to the machine file created by collecting the
statements coded *z2 NIC in the Master Catalog.
The data element *z1 indicates which Stations hold a copy of an item;
not all items related to NIC are sent to Stations, and in the future
it is expected that Stations will submit many documents to NIC for
cataloging which are not held by other Stations.
Watson & North [Page 2]
RFC 115 Policies on Handling Documents 16 April 1971
NIC CATALOG LISTINGS AND INDEXES
Programs have been written at ARC to collect, sort, analyze and
format the statements and the data elements in the statements to
produce catalogs and indexes such as those in the Current Catalog of
the NIC Collection, NIC (5145,).
The Current Catalog of the NIC Collection is a functional document,
as explained in Branch 3 below. It has as its contents, at any time,
the current issue of a bibliography of items from the NIC Catalog,
called a NIC Catalog Listing, and author and keyword indexes.
Examples of entries in the Catalog Listing and in indexes are shown,
using the statement above:
Catalog Listing by Author:
An NCP for the ARPA Network
James E. White (University of 5480 White
California at Santa Barbara)
21 December 1970
Describes program designed and
implemented at node of ARPA Network,
written in assembly language and
implemented on 360/75.
Discusses interface with hardware,
software, and operator.
Catalog Listing by NIC number:
An NCP for the ARPA Network 5480
James E. White (University of
California at Santa Barbara)
21 December 1970
Describes program designed and implemented
at node of ARPA Network, written in
assembly language and implemented on
360/75. Discusses interface with
hardware, software, and operator.
Watson & North [Page 3]
RFC 115 Policies on Handling Documents 16 April 1971
Author Index:
Subject: Education Status, memo to 5456 Westlund
An NCP for the ARPA Network 5480 White
NWG/RFC 78 (NCP Status Report 5199 White
Titleworld Index:
Natural Communication with Computers 5639 Natural
An NCP for the ARPA Network 5480 Network
Proposal for a Network Interchange 4752 Network
A NIC Catalog Listing will indicate those items held in the Station
Collections either by a separate listing or by a notation with each
reference. A number catalog or index serves as a shelf list of
documents held by a Station. The indexes are not limited to the
Station Collections but lead to the entire Catalog.
DATA ELEMENTS
The data elements for information items include the author, title,
addressee, date, other numbers, keywords, and abstract. When these
elements do not exist in the item, they are supplied by a NIC
cataloger if possible. In online communication around the Network,
"online dialog", several of these elements of data will be recorded
automatically. Lacking online recording, it is important that
originators of reports, memos, and other such items be diligent in
including these data in their transmissions.
For memos, essential data elements which the originator
should supply are:.
author(s)
address(es) of author(s)
addressee(s)
address(es) of addressee(s)
date of origination
subject of memo
A preassigned NIC number is desirable. A number for
assignment can presently be obtained by calling NIC, and
soon will be obtainable online.
The addressees of a memo can of course be a group, such
as the Network Working Group, or the Glitch Cleaning
Committee, in which case the NIC needs a list or
reference to a list of the people in the group.
Watson & North [Page 4]
RFC 115 Policies on Handling Documents 16 April 1971
For reports and other formal documents, essential data
elements are:
author(s)
addresses of author(s)
title
date
abstract
keywords
A short abstract, 150 to 200 words, giving some of the
substance of the document is of importance in the NIC
record and even for the person about to read the
document. Obviously, a well-written author abstract is
preferable to one produced by the NIC staff.
Keywords supplied by the author, preferably those from a
standard thesaurus, will be used in machine retrieval.
When such author-assigned keywords are lacking, the NIC
will supply some. Recommended sources for keywords are:
Categories identified by Peggy Karp, Categorization
and Guide to NWG/RFC's. NIC 5819.
American National Standard Vocabulary for Information
Processing, ANSI X3.12-1970. NIC 5827.
Department of Defense, Thesaurus of Engineering and
Scientific Terms, 1967, AD 672 000. NIC 5829.
NASA Thesaurus, December 1967. NASA SP-7030. NIC
5828.
When a document being issued supercedes an earlier
document, this information is particularly important, and
should be supplied by the author.
SUBCOLLECTIONS
Groups of documents, such as the NWG/RFC's and the replies to Sher's
survey, as well as the Station Collections, are cataloged by NIC as
subcollections. That is, they are retrievable as a subset of the NIC
Catalog, which in turn is a subset of a Master Catalog at ARC. The
capability of making subcollections is provided for Network
participants.
Watson & North [Page 5]
RFC 115 Policies on Handling Documents 16 April 1971
To create a subcollection in the NIC records, a Network
participant will be able to indicate to NIC the records he wishes
to have so grouped, and this information will be entered in the
Master Catalog statement for the document, for later retrieval.
FUNCTIONAL DOCUMENTS
Several documents generated in Network activities are subject to
occasional revision and updating. The NIC Catalog, the Directory of
Network Participants, and the Directory of Network Resources are
examples. These and external documents such as the BBN manuals are
referred to by NIC as "functional documents".
More generally, a functional document is a document whose title
and function remain constant, but whose contents can change. A
functional document contains a single or several documents which
can be added to, deleted, or replaced entirely or selectively.
Thus the functional document, which has a NIC number, can be
referenced in other documents with some assurance that it will be
in existence, even though the subdocuments with their distinctive
NIC numbers may be in flux. In the Catalog, the number of a
functional document in which a specific document may be contained
is listed, and the current contents of each functional document is
indicated.
In preparing a document which is expected to be revised, Network
participants are urged to use a looseleaf format.
The Network Information Center intends to support the distribution
and recording of contents of functional documents. Procedures have
been established, as described below, for fitting the changes to such
documents into the NIC system, and for reproducing and distributing
them to individuals or stations with instructions for their
integration into the existing documents.
PROCEDURES FOR REVISION MATERIAL
Original manuals and other functional document materials are
reproduced and distributed by NIC just as other Network publications.
For all documents obtained through NIC, NIC will attempt to receive
and make distribution of updates.
NIC also wants to make the processes of inserting the revisions and
of recording the changes as easy and foolproof as possible. The user
should not only be given the current materials, but should be able to
determine the version he holds, and to be able to refer to updates
uniquely. The following is copied from the procedure instructions
Watson & North [Page 6]
RFC 115 Policies on Handling Documents 16 April 1971
NIC has written for its own use. These procedures are also
recommended to Network participants for their use in preparing
revision material to be sent to NIC.
Update conventions
Substantial revision of a bound document, or of more than a few
pages of a loose leaf document:
A new document will be published, with a new NIC number,
and will bear a notation under the number on the title
page and/or cover, e.g.,
NIC 5772
supercedes NIC 5621
Few pages inserted or revised in a looseleaf or
corner-stapled document:
Each new or revised page will bear the original document
number, with a notice of revision, e.g.,
NIC 5742
3-10-71
Inserted pages will be numbered to fit into the existing
document, e.g., pages 5.1, 5.2, 5.3, may be inserted
between pages 5 and 6.
Deleted pages will be replaced by a single page
indicating the deletion, e.g.,
Pages 7-12 deleted, 3-25-71
A new table of contents and/or title page will be issued
bearing the revision notice. In addition, at the time of
each revision a page or pages will be prepared and
issued which indicates all additions, deletions, and
revisions which bring the document up to date.
Revisions will be made only by substitution, addition or deletion
of a full page or more. NIC will not revise its own publications
by lists of errata, and strongly recommends against their use by
others in the Network. However, when NIC receives such lists of
errata, it will reproduce and distribute them with suggestions to
Station Agents for recording and inserting them.
Watson & North [Page 7]
RFC 115 Policies on Handling Documents 16 April 1971
Distribution and transmittal procedures
The transmittal letter accompanying a set of revision material and
the revision material itself constitute a separate document, a
copy of which is filed at NIC, where a new copy can be provided at
any time.
The transmittal letter will indicate the appropriate information;
document number of the revision material, date, document number of
the publication being updated, its date, and, when practicable,
information on the changes made in the text.
Revision notation in the printed Catalogs and their indexes
Catalog entry
Supercession
The data element containing "superceded by NIC xxxx"
will be formatted to appear at the beginning of the
citation of the superceded document.
The data element containing "supercedes NIC xxxx"
will be formatted to appear following the abstract in
the citation.
Partial revision
The data element containing the note of revision will
be formatted to appear following the abstract.
Entries in author, titleworld, or other indexes
Supercession
The data element covering supercession will be the
only text in the entry for the superceded document.
Supercession will not be indicated in the entry for
the superceding document
Partial revision
Partial revision will not be indicated in the index
entry
[ This RFC was put into machine readable form for entry ]
[ into the online RFC archives by Jay Kominek 2/99 ]
Watson & North [Page 8]
RFC, FYI, BCP